Close Menu
    Categories
    CISS Logo
    Center For International Strategic Studies
    Latest
    Blog

    A Tale of Two Indian Disinformation Labs

    Usman Ali KhanBy Usman Ali KhanUpdated:1,066 Comments6 Mins Read

    In an ever-evolving landscape of information and disinformation, a variety of terms have emerged to describe related occurrences. These include misinformation, disinformation, conspiracy theories, fake news, misperceptions, rumors, fifth-generation warfare, and propaganda, among others. In recent years, two organizations with deceptively similar names have emerged as significant players in spreading propaganda and disinformation. The first is the Brussels-based EU Disinfo Lab, while the other is the New Delhi-based .Disinfo Lab.

    The former i.e. the EU Disinfo Lab is known for its 2020 report titled “Indian Chronicles,” that exposed a network targeting the EU and UN with pro-Indian content and maligning Pakistan, for over a decade. The latter i.e. the Disinfo Lab was established in 2023 and gained prominence for its media reports exposing Indian media warfare fueled by misinformation and disinformation while running covert influence operations.

    Despite apparent similarity of their names, both entities operate with vastly different methodologies, objectives, and scopes.

    Since 2020, the EU Disinfo Lab released extensive reports and social media content under the title “Indian Chronicles – Subsequent Investigation: Deep Dive into a 15-Year Operation Targeting the EU and UN to Serve Indian Interests.” These reports revealed ties between the Indian government and a fake news website, surprising many fact-checkers. This report shows the extent to which India resurrected a dead professor and numerous defunct organizations and used alongside at least 750 fake media outlets to serve Indian interests, under the leadership of PM Modi. These defunct has been relying on lies to discredit nations primarily Pakistan, and China to a certain extent.

    This whole campaign was aimed at bolstering India’s global perception, a sort of information laundering, with the ultimate aim of allowing it to garner more support from international institutions such as the EU and the UN. By pursuing its agenda of discrediting Pakistan,it effectively promoted Indian interests at the UN conferences and hearings, and thus benefited India.

    Interestingly, Indian disinformation operations via cyber-meddling did not stop after the ‘EU Disinfo Labs’ incriminating revelations and comprehensive evidence. The propaganda continued but this time with a new name and new motive i.e. the New Delhi-based ‘Disinfo Lab’.

    As detailed in reports by the Washington Post on 10 Dec 23, this ‘Disinfo Lab’ is closely linked to Indians including Lt. Col. Dibya Satpathy of India’s infamous Research and Analysis Wing (RAW). RAW has recently been a subject of debate with respect to its assassination attempts on foreign soils notably in Canada and the USA. Coming back to the ‘Disinfo Lab’, which was founded around 2020 and based in New Delhi, it is known for its covert operations targeting foreign critics of the Indian government and PM Modi.

    The Disinfo Lab campaigns, which originally focused on bolstering domestic support and disparaging opposition parties, later extended their reach beyond India’s borders, aiming to influence attitudes on a global scale. The extensive dossier and social media posts reveal that the BJP government propagates conspiracy theories based on half-truths about a supposed shadowy network of political activists and ‘enemies’ of India, including in the United States.  

    The EU Disinfo Lab and the Disinfo Lab reports highlight that Indian disinformation campaigns have always been nefarious endeavors to serve Indian interests both at international and national levels. Such networks are also part of the sinister propaganda campaign, which includes India’s active involvement in creating terrorist and separatist activities in Pakistan’s Balochistan province, sabotaging CPEC, and subverting Pakistan’s economic progress.

    PM Modi has been sworn in as India’s prime minister for a third term. During his election campaign, the core of its message had been a diverse range of conspiracy theories making waves on social media that ultimately has been helping him gain the higher ground again. This is also evident from the fact where the recent seizure of commercial equipment destined to Pakistan on suspicions of nuclear proliferation by Indian authorities, serves as a prime illustration of how distorting facts lays the groundwork for advancing geopolitical agendas. Such tactics have always been used by India with an aim to isolate Islamabad and undermine its global standing by portraying it as an irresponsible State. It is also not a surprise that New Delhi has always been very successful in conveniently sweeping its own misdoings under the rug as evident from the ‘Da Cui Yun Debacle’ in Feb 2020 and the ‘BrahMos missile misfire incident’ of 9 March 2022. Such Indian misinformation and conspiracy theories — tinted with nationalist sentiment —reveal the arrogance of the BJP government and its governing Hindu nationalist thinking to consolidate its attempts at supremacy in South Asia.

    What can be inferred from these revelations concerning disinformation campaigns affecting regional dynamics aimed at Pakistan is that Pakistan is confronting a novel form of hybrid warfare, incorporating strategies spanning from traditional explosives to automated programs, indicating a transformation in regional dynamics. Not only this, but the assertive aggressive Hindu nationalist foreign policy is highly destabilizing for the region as evident from the revocation of Kashmir’s autonomy in 2019. There are substantial proofs that New Delhi provides support to terrorist forces in areas like Balochistan province, providing them with money, weapons, and training that has escalated tensions in South Asia.  India as a State has increasingly become synonymous with lies, deceit, and fakery. Despite it, unfortunately, it is unlikely that the reports that have extensively uncovered a network of disinformation being run by India will alter India’s international standing. It is so because, the Western powers see India as a potential counterweight to growing Chinese influence in the region and beyond, irrespective of all the facts. The BJP government will keep playing the disinformation card against both Pakistan and China to neutralize its domestic challenges and to counter any negativity regarding it internationally. This puts the onus of countering such narrative on both China and Pakistan. There is a need to devise a collective strategy by both Pakistan and China to counter India’s disinformation industry in today’s mass media and debunk such disinformation to safeguard national as well as mutual interests.

    Usman Ali Khan
    + posts
    Share.

    Related Posts

    View 1,066 Comments

    1,066 Comments

    1. Tressa Burgoyne on

      Hi!

      It is with sad regret to inform you that LeadsBox.biz is shutting down.

      We have made all our databases available to the public.

      25 Million Companies!
      527 Million People!
      145 Countries!

      Come visit us on LeadsBox.biz

      Reply
    4. Irish Painter on

      Ready to discover how to create easy sales funnels? With the right AI, you can build engaging pages that turn leads into customers. This tool assists you through every step, from writing to optimization, making it easy to achieve your sales goals. Everything becomes simpler and more efficient! Find out how to get started today! https://bit.ly/Skyrocket-Your-Sales

      Reply
    5. Betty Mathis on

      Want to increase profits fast and effortlessly? With intelligent AI, you can now create high-converting funnels in record time! This tool is designed for those who seek real, visible sales results. In just minutes, you’ll have optimized sales pages and compelling copy, ready to attract your audience and turn them into buyers. Everything you need for success is right here. Learn more here! https://bit.ly/Skyrocket-Your-Sales

      Reply
    9. Anya170mi on

      Hello everyone!
      I came across a 170 useful site that I think you should browse.
      This tool is packed with a lot of useful information that you might find interesting.
      It has everything you could possibly need, so be sure to give it a visit!
      https://www.theproche.com/2022/02/25/top-5-quiz-constructors-for-businesses-and-individuals/

      Additionally remember not to forget, everyone, — a person constantly may in this particular publication locate answers to your most confusing inquiries. The authors tried to present all information in the most easy-to-grasp method.

      Reply
    16. Jamespounc on

      Interested in UFC? https://ufc-white-house.com unique mixed martial arts tournament will take place on June 14, 2026, in Washington, D.C., on the South Lawn of the White House. It will be the first professional sporting event in history to be held directly on the grounds of the U.S. presidential residence.

      Reply
    26. MichaelGeami on

      Нужен финаносвый план? https://financedirector.by/investicionnyj-biznes-plan-struktura-i-primer-dlja-investorov/ подробное объяснение структуры документа, его роли в привлечении инвесторов, получении кредита и запуске бизнеса. Узнайте, какие разделы включает бизнес-план, какие расчеты нужны и как он помогает оценить прибыльность проекта.

      Reply
    32. TerryDex on

      Сладкий слот для вас https://sweetbonanza2500.info яркий онлайн-слот с конфетной тематикой и увеличенным потенциалом выигрыша. Каскадные символы, множители и бонусные фриспины создают динамичный игровой процесс с шансом на крупные выплаты.

      Reply
    33. Raymondswire on

      Играешь в казино? https://nodepositcasino.top обзоры онлайн-казино, актуальные бездепозитные бонусы, фриспины и акции для новых игроков. Узнайте условия получения бонусов и начните играть без вложений.

      Reply
    35. Andresreicy on

      Лучшие слоты онлайн https://sugar-rush-slot.top красочный слот с цепными выигрышами и накопительными множителями. Игра отличается простым управлением, ярким дизайном и высоким потенциалом выигрыша при удачных комбинациях.

      Reply
    39. AlfredoVew on

      Быстрая профессиональная установка камер видеонаблюдения для квартир, домов, офисов и коммерческих объектов. Проектирование, монтаж и настройка систем безопасности, удалённый доступ, запись видео и контроль в реальном времени. Надёжные решения для защиты имущества и контроля территории.

      Reply
    41. WillisSaw on

      Быстрая профессиональная установка камер видеонаблюдения для квартир, домов, офисов и коммерческих объектов. Проектирование, монтаж и настройка систем безопасности, удалённый доступ, запись видео и контроль в реальном времени. Надёжные решения для защиты имущества и контроля территории.

      Reply
    44. Anya173mi on

      Hello guys!
      I came across a 173 awesome site that I think you should check out.
      This tool is packed with a lot of useful information that you might find interesting.
      It has everything you could possibly need, so be sure to give it a visit!
      https://urominsas.com/how-to-begin-sports-betting-online-safely/

      And do not neglect, guys, which a person at all times can within the piece find answers for the the absolute tangled queries. Our team tried to present the complete information using an very accessible method.

      Reply
    49. Raymondrak on

      pin up|pin up casino|pin-up oyunu|pin-up online casino|pin up az|pin-up 141 casino|pin up azerbaycan|pin up 360 casino giriş|pin-up casino indir|pin up giriş|pin up kazino|pin up casino azerbaijan

      Reply
    58. Anya174mi on

      Hello team!
      I came across a 174 helpful tool that I think you should explore.
      This resource is packed with a lot of useful information that you might find insightful.
      It has everything you could possibly need, so be sure to give it a visit!
      https://thehake.com/2022/10/diversity-and-culture-through-food/

      Additionally remember not to overlook, folks, which you always may within the piece discover solutions for your most complicated queries. The authors made an effort to present all of the information in the most very understandable method.

      Reply
    89. Anya174mi on

      Hello !!
      I came across a 174 fantastic platform that I think you should explore.
      This resource is packed with a lot of useful information that you might find insightful.
      It has everything you could possibly need, so be sure to give it a visit!
      https://kyahotahai.in/going-forward-with-online-slots-strategy/

      And remember not to neglect, everyone, which a person at all times are able to inside this particular article discover responses to the the absolute tangled inquiries. Our team attempted to lay out the complete information via an most easy-to-grasp way.

      Reply
    129. MichaelCam on

      Онлайн-сервис оценки недвижимости https://shalmach.pro по фотографиям для покупки, аренды и планирования ремонта. Узнайте ориентировочную стоимость жилья, возможные вложения и рекомендации перед принятием решения.

      Reply
    239. sdasteam 354 on

      Steam Desktop Authenticator https://sdasteam.com (SDA). It allows you to generate account login codes and automatically confirm trades or item sales on the Community Market without using your smartphone.

      Reply
    241. Anya176mi on

      Hello team!
      I came across a 176 great website that I think you should take a look at.
      This tool is packed with a lot of useful information that you might find insightful.
      It has everything you could possibly need, so be sure to give it a visit!
      https://www.golfsportmagazin.de/golfnews/vermischtes/so-kann-man-als-golf-fan-geld-verdienen/

      Furthermore don’t overlook, folks, which a person always may in this article locate solutions for your most tangled inquiries. Our team attempted to present all of the content via the extremely accessible method.

      Reply
    253. Anya176mi on

      Hello pals!
      I came across a 176 very cool site that I think you should visit.
      This platform is packed with a lot of useful information that you might find interesting.
      It has everything you could possibly need, so be sure to give it a visit!
      https://thefinalmatrix.com/tips-to-help-an-artist-find-his-style/

      Additionally remember not to neglect, everyone, — you always can inside this article find responses for the the very confusing questions. We attempted to explain all of the information in an extremely easy-to-grasp way.

      Reply
    988. RobertDetly on

      Everything for Minecraft https://topminecraftworldseeds.com/ in one place: mods, skins, maps, texture packs, and the best seeds for survival, creativity, and adventure. Collections of popular add-ons, installation instructions, updates, and secure downloads for different versions of the game.

      Reply
    1013. RobertDetly on

      Everything for Minecraft https://topminecraftworldseeds.com/ in one place: mods, skins, maps, texture packs, and the best seeds for survival, creativity, and adventure. Collections of popular add-ons, installation instructions, updates, and secure downloads for different versions of the game.

      Reply
    1063. RobertDetly on

      Everything for Minecraft https://topminecraftworldseeds.com/ in one place: mods, skins, maps, texture packs, and the best seeds for survival, creativity, and adventure. Collections of popular add-ons, installation instructions, updates, and secure downloads for different versions of the game.

      Reply
    Leave A Reply

    CISS

    Center for International Strategic Studies

    Center for Strategic and International Studies 43-Orchard Boulevard, Chak Shehzad, Islamabad, Pakistan

    Tel: +92-51-8315410-423

    Fax: +92-51-6132518

    SUBSCRIBE TO CISS NEWSLETTER

    FOLLOW US

    Center for Strategic & International Studies. All Rights Reserved.

    • Accessibility
    • Privacy Policy
    • Reprint Permissions
    Center for Strategic and International Studies 43-Orchard Boulevard, Chak Shehzad, Islamabad, Pakistan

    Tel: +92-51-8315410-423
    Fax: +92-51-6132518

    See Media Page for more interview, contact, and citation details.

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    Subscribe to CSIS
    Newsletter

    FOLLOW

    Center for Strategic & International Studies. All Rights Reserved.

    • Accessibility
    • Privacy Policy
    • Reprint Permissions